The impact of practical experience on theoretical knowledge at different cognitive levels

Journal of the South African Veterinary Association


 
 
Field Value
 
Title The impact of practical experience on theoretical knowledge at different cognitive levels
 
Creator Leask, Rhoda Cronje, Tanita Holm, Dietmar E. van Ryneveld, Linda
 
Subject Education; Veterinary Science education; small ruminants; veterinary graduates; curriculum design; practical experience; theoretical education; assessment
Description Although theoretical training of veterinary students is uncomplicated even for larger groups, practical training remains a challenge. Much has been said about the value of practical training in curriculum design. Yet, the impact of practical training on theoretical knowledge needs further research. A cohort of 89 students with very limited clinical practical experience completed an assessment at the end of their theoretical training in small ruminants. The scores obtained by the students were compared with those obtained by a group of 35 veterinarians who volunteered to participate in the study. In addition to comparing the scores between students and practitioners, the cognitive level of each of the questions was considered. Overall, veterinarians achieved higher test scores than did the students. The veterinarians outperformed the students in all cognitive levels except for ‘applying’ type questions where there was no difference. Different levels of experience, namely young veterinarians (n = 11), established veterinarians (n = 13) and veterinarians approaching retirement (n = 11), were evaluated against the revised Bloom’s cognitive levels. When modelling congress attendance frequency, years’ experience, proportion of time spent with ruminants and revised Bloom’s levels, congress attendance was not a significant variable, and thus, only the other three variables remained. This investigation found that practical experience has a positive effect on theoretical knowledge. The type of practical experience and where such practical experience is included in a curriculum need further research. Working for a number of years in a specific discipline will provide the best support for theoretical knowledge.
 
Publisher AOSIS
 
Contributor University of Pretoria
Date 2020-07-29
 
Type info:eu-repo/semantics/article info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion — Mixed method; Qualitative and quantitative; Survey
Format text/html application/epub+zip text/xml application/pdf
Identifier 10.4102/jsava.v91i0.2042
 
Source Journal of the South African Veterinary Association; Vol 91 (2020); 7 pages 2224-9435 1019-9128
 
Language eng
 
Relation https://jsava.co.za/index.php/jsava/article/view/2042/2598 https://jsava.co.za/index.php/jsava/article/view/2042/2597 https://jsava.co.za/index.php/jsava/article/view/2042/2599 https://jsava.co.za/index.php/jsava/article/view/2042/2596
 
Coverage Southern Africa — All ages, genders and ethnicity within South Africa
Rights Copyright (c) 2020 Rhoda Leask, Tanita Cronje, Dietmar E. Holm, Linda van Ryneveld https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0